Understanding the Sikh Community in the Wake of Tragedy

Who are Sikhs? Take a look into what Sikhism is.

At least 700 attacks against Sikhs since 9/11 (Credit: CNN), with the latest occuring in Oak Creek, Wisconsin at Gurdwara (Sikh Temple).

Since Sept. 11th, Sikhs, like other Americans, have been grappling with grief and fear. But their fear is not only about another assault from outside. Many Sikhs have become victims of hate crimes because of their appearance. Balbir Singh Sodhi, a Sikh American (Balbir Singh Sodhi), was killed on Sept. 15 as a result of mistaken identity.Across America, the only people who wear turbans are followers of the Sikh religion. Sikhs are from Northern India (Punjab) and are neither Hindus nor Muslims.

Sikhs at a Glance:

  • 99 percent of people wearing turbans in the U.S. are Sikhs from India.
  • Sikhs have been in the U.S. for over 100 years.
  • There are roughly 700,000 Sikhs in the U.S. today.
  • Sikhism is the world’s fifth largest religion with 25 million adherents worldwide.
  • Sikhs believe in one God, equality, freedom of religion, and community service.
  • Sikhs cover their uncut hair with a turban.
  • Among the Sikhs, the turban is an article of faith that represents, honor, self- respect, courage, spirituality, and piety.
  • Sikhism is a distinct religion, separate from Hinduism and Islam.


Sikhism - The word Sikh (pronounced "sickh") means 'disciple' or 'learner.' The Sikh religion was founded in Northern India in the 15th century by Guru Nanak Dev Ji and is distinct from Islam and Hinduism.

Sikhism is monotheistic and stresses the equality of all men and women. Sikhs believe in three basic principles; meditating on the name of God (praying), earning a living by honest means as well as sharing the fruits of one’s labor with others. Sikhism rejects caste and class systems and emphasizes service to humanity. Turbans are worn to cover our long hair and with respect to God.

Learn to recognize a Sikh turban

Sikhs have unshorn hair, beards and moustaches. The Sikh faith teaches us the humanitarian principles of freedom, equality, and justice - the same principles this great democracy is founded on. There are about 25 million Sikhs in the world. Sikhs have been in the United States for over 100 years.

Sikhism recognizes the universal truths that underlie all human endeavors, religions and belief systems. The universal nature of the Sikh way of life reaches out to people of all faiths and cultural backgrounds, encouraging us to see beyond our differences and to work together for world peace and harmony.

History and Beliefs

The almost 25 million Sikhs worldwide constitute the fifth largest religion in the world. Despite almost one million Sikhs living in North America (USA and Canada), Sikhs are often confused as Arabs or Muslims. Sikhs arrived in North America in 1897 and played a pivotal role in the opening of the West and construction of the Panama Canal in 1904, according to several sources including Wikipedia.

In 1906, Sikhs established their first Gurdwara, or place of worship, in the United States. There are 700,000 Americans and Canadians of Sikh faith and nearly every major city has a Sikh place of worship and community center.

The Sikh faith is 500 years old. Guru Nanak, the founder of Sikhism, taught a message of love. He spoke of a universal God, common to all mankind, not limited to any religion, nation, race, creed, color, or gender.

The Sikh religion is strictly monotheistic, believing in one supreme Creator, free of gender, absolute, all-pervading, and eternal. Sikhism views life not as a fall from grace, but a unique opportunity to discover and develop the divinity in each of us.

Human rights and justice form a cornerstone of Sikh belief, and Sikh history features countless examples of Sikh Gurus and their followers making tremendous sacrifices for the cause of religious freedom and justice.

More recently, Sikhs have been some of the most highly decorated soldiers of the British armed services during both World Wars. They played a significant role in the memorable battles of El Alamein in the Burma-China front and also in the allied assault in Italy.

In India’s struggle for independence from the British, over two-thirds of all the Indians who were sentenced to life imprisonment or death were Sikh. This is in spite of the fact that Sikhs form less than two percent of India’s population.

The Sikh Identity

In 1699, the tenth and last living Sikh Guru, Guru Gobind Singh, summoned his
followers to the town of Anandpur in Punjab; over 80,000 came.

According to history, Guru Gobind Singh appeared before his people, flashed a naked sword, and demanded a head. He repeated his call until five Sikhs volunteered. These five individuals came from different parts of India and from different castes.

To these five, and subsequently to many others on that historic day, Guru Gobind Singh bestowed a new discipline, a creed to his Sikhs. The Guru initiated these five in the new order of the Khalsa and then, in a dramatic and historic gesture, they in turn initiated him. On that day, he gave the Sikhs a unique identity which includes five articles of faith:

  • Unshorn hair as a gift of God and Guru and a mark of Sikh identity.
  • A small comb for the hair.
  • A steel bracelet which signifies a reality with no beginning and no end, and is also symbolic of a Sikh’s commitment to the ideals of his faith, much as wedding ring might indicate fealty and identity.
  • A sword indicative of resolve and commitment to justice, and.
  • Knee-length breeches in keeping with the disciplined life-style of a Sikh.


For the past 300 years, male Sikhs have been easily recognized by their long unshorn hair covered with a turban. In traditional Indian society, only males of high caste or the elite, ruling class wore turbans. In requiring all Sikhs to don turbans, Guru Gobind Singh envisioned all individuals as noble. Sikh women adhere to the same life style, symbols, rules and conduct, but relatively few choose to wear turbans. Young Sikh boys, instead of wearing a turban, often cover their uncut hair, which is tied in a top-knot, with a simple piece of fabric.

Along with the aforementioned physical identifiers, Guru Gobind Singh went further in distinguishing Sikhs. In Indian society, an individual’s name reveals one’s caste and social status. Guru Gobind Singh freed Sikhs from the rigid caste system by ordering all Sikh males adopt the surname “Singh,” meaning a lion, and women use the surname“Kaur” meaning princess, thus shedding their caste identity.

Each year, Sikhs worldwide commemorate and celebrate the historic events of Vaisakhi 1699 as a milestone in Sikh history when Guru Gobind Singh decreed the formation of the Khalsa and fashioned the nation of Sikhs.

The Sikh Scripture
Guru Gobind Singh also decreed an end to the line of Gurus in human form. The writings of the earlier Gurus were collated along with those of Hindu and Muslim spiritual figures whose teachings strongly resonated with Sikh beliefs.

This collection of writings is known as Guru Granth Sahib, a uniquely ecumenical and eclectic collection of spiritual writings. For Sikhs, Guru Granth Sahib is the repository of all spiritual knowledge and authority. In temporal matters all authority rests with the Sikh community worldwide acting democratically and in mindful prayer with an awareness of the spiritual heritage which is embodied in the Guru Granth.

Sikhs revere the ten Gurus, Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind Singh, because they delivered the divine word of the one, timeless God. The word “Guru” acquires, therefore, a very special meaning for Sikhs. It is reserved only for the ten Gurus who gave us the divine message and to this message contained in the Guru Granth Sahib.

The Gurdwara

The Sikh place of worship, or Gurdwara, is more than a place of worship. It has historically served as a refuge for the homeless and the destitute. Gurdwaras usually display the Nishan Sahib, a saffron-colored triangular flag bearing the Khanda, the symbol of the Sikh faith. Visitors, irrespective of their religion, are offered shelter, comfort, and food. The prerequisites for entering a Gurdwara are removing shoes and covering one’s head with a handkerchief, scarf, or other cloth.

In a Gurdwara, no special place or seat may be reserved or set aside for any dignitary, as all are considered equals. The service consists of singing of the liturgy, as well as the exposition of Sikh history, tradition, and theology.

Non-Sikhs are always welcome.

Sikh gurdwaras all over the world usually run free community kitchens, which provide meals to all. These kitchens are run and funded by volunteers. In traditional Indian society, people of high and low caste were rigidly segregated. To combat this social problem, the Sikh community kitchen, or langar, requires everyone to sit side by side and eat together, thereby teaching the concept of equality by shattering all barriers of caste and class. Every major city in the United States and Canada has Sikh gurdwaras and they are open to all.

The Sikh Way of Life
Sikhism is a practical religion and Sikhs are a pragmatic people. The emphasis is on a leading a worldly, successful life as a householder and a contributing member of society, but with the mind attuned to an awareness of God.

Sikhism rejects all distinctions based on caste, creed, gender, color, race, or national origin. For Sikhs, God is not found in isolation or by renouncing the world, but is attained as an active family member and member of one’s community. The word “Sikh”means student. Therefore, a Sikh is and remains a student of the meaning of life. The core values of Sikhism are derived from three equally important tenets: an honest living and an honest day’s work, sharing with others what God and life have given, and living life fully with an awareness of the divine within each of us.

Sikhism enunciates a philosophical concept termed Miri-Piri, which means living a life with an active, strong sense of commitment to the world and humanity, governed and directed by a strong foundation and underpinning of spirituality. Thus, the Sikh ideal is to strike a perfect balance and integration of these two states of existence.

In matters that affect the Sikh community, Sikhs have throughout history followed a simple but effective mechanism whereby individual voices are heard and decisions reflect the current state of knowledge, information and technology. In all such matters, and in honor of the first five Sikhs who heeded the call of Guru Gobind Singh in 1699, the voice of the community is channeled through five initiated Sikhs selected and authorized to resolve issues and speak as the voice of the community. Sikhs believe that God and Guru pervade the congregation when five Sikhs act in mindful prayer. Decision making, thus, becomes a collective process. Sikhs do not have a priestly hierarchy with its associated ecclesiastical authority.


The Sikh faith is committed to the equality of women, and necessarily so, as it defines God as gender neutral, perhaps one of the few major world religions to do so. There is no activity in a gurdwara or within the community that is permitted to a man but not to a woman. There is no religious function from which women are barred at any time of their lives.

Dietary Restrictions

Sikhs have no food taboos except those that stem from one simple injunction – a life of moderation in which we shun all that harms the body or the mind. Animal sacrifice is forbidden and so is the consumption of animals killed in such manner. This also means that all intoxicants – tobacco, alcohol or any mind altering “recreational” drugs – are forbidden.

Other Religions

Sikhism recognizes the universal truths that underlie all human endeavors, religions, and belief systems, though people differ in how they institutionalize those beliefs into a code of conduct and a way of life. Much as Sikhs love their religion, Sikhism is equally respectful and accepting of other ways of life and beliefs. Sikhism asks a non-Sikh to discover and live the essential message and meaning of his or her own religion so that a Christian can become a better Christian, Jew a better Jew, Hindu a better Hindu, while a Sikh becomes a better Sikh.

Related Links:
1. .
2. .

This blog has been adapted from “Sikhs and their Religion” by Dr. IJ Singh and from SALDEF.org by Manmohan (Manny) Singh Bharara, co-founder of Gurdwara Guru Nanak Darbar 160 West St. in Southington, and founder of Gurdwara Sachkhand Darbar, 336 Welton St. in Hamden. (Both are Sikh Faith Religious Organizations.)

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Rogers Chapstick August 08, 2012 at 08:32 PM
Tchjjal, you only need to look towards the nonsensical argument over gay rights. Freedom is every person's right, no matter their race, religion, or sexual tendencies. But to argue against making that freedom legal? That argument is being spurred on primarily by Christians. I have no problem with Christianity, or Islam, or Hinduism, but when members of those religions commit hateful acts in the name of that religion, there is a problem. I don't want to make this a thing, but you really don't have a full understanding of the health law where"the government is telling the church they have to provide birth control". The Church itself isn't providing birth control. Your friendly neighborhood pastor isn't giving out condoms with his blessing by the holy water. The law only brings the Catholic-affiliated schools, hospitals, etc. under the same health insurance laws as everyone else. When you force your beliefs on others, that is called persecution. As for the Sikh tragedy, it truly is awful. As far as my understanding goes, the Sikh people are a very honorable people as a whole, and their belief system provides many teachings involving the care of those less fortunate. Your Friend, Rogers Chapstick
Paul Chotkowski August 08, 2012 at 09:10 PM
Mr. F. a typical Progressive / Socialist spin. The alignment of the Marxists like yourself with pro Caliphate Muslims is getting harder and harder to hide. Verifiable fact: The lines of Quran quoted earlier are widely taught TODAY, let me say that again WIDELY TAUGHT TODAY in Madrassas and preached by Imams in Mosques throughout the Islamic world as justification for violence in general and most notably the call for the overthrow and death of the Great Satan [Shaytân-e Bozorg or Al-Shaytan Al-Akbar] and by extension the Western way of life. Follow the translation work of The Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI) and see what Imams and politicians are saying in Arabic and Farsi [rather than their sanitized English statements]. Heck, even watch Al Jazeerah TV or RT [Russia Today] and you will see for yourself what is said at Friday prayer or at political rallies when English speaking “press” are not present. Yes there are Christian wacko’s, see the Westboro Baptist Church if you have doubts. But I have never been to a Christian service of any denomination [and I attend quite a few] that has called for death to the Amalekites, Samarians, Sabians, Jews, other Christians or Muslims. In fact you should stop by a Christians United for Israel (CUFI) meeting sometime, now that would challenge your socialist Utopian worldview [probably not]! Consider cowboying up and using your real first and last name that way you could use courage and conviction in the same sentence!
tchjjal August 08, 2012 at 09:11 PM
Rogers, sorry, but for you to tell me and other Christians that we have to agree and/or vote yes for legislation that gives special rights to an ungodly sexual orientated group is wrong. There is no argument there! We are to treat homosexuals kind and lovingly....and not to turn away anyone in business, etc. but we don't agree with their lifestyle.... Some society's accept it more...same with pedophilia but it's still wrong according to God. As for the church providing birth control, I thought you were smart enough to figure that out.....Obamacare is mandating that the catholic church provide contraceptive coverage! They are definitely stepping over the line! I don't care if you agree with our beliefs...most people don't and this is exactly what I'm talking about in this country when I say we are the most persecuted group in the world. You are just one of many jumping on the band wagon to insult the christians.... This was a nice article about the Sikh tragedy, but I had to speak out when Rockfall Resident called the killer of these people a Christian extremist terrorist. He was not a Christian. As for the comment about the Sikh people being honorable, we as Christians send money to "those less fortunate" too.....but people don't want to hear or believe that either....
Rockfall Resident August 08, 2012 at 09:32 PM
Here is some examples. I am Christian, but saying there isn't blatant discrimination based on Muslim background is downright ignorant. http://www.humanrightsfirst.org/wp-content/uploads/pdf/3-2010-muslim-factsheet-update.pdf
Rockfall Resident August 08, 2012 at 09:34 PM
In our country you must accept their ability to exist. This does not mean you must accept their beliefs as your own. But you at wron, as an American it is your duty to accept their ability to have their set of beliefs
WorldTraveler August 08, 2012 at 09:43 PM
Thank you for providing this information on the Sikh community. It was very interesting and informative. Peace be with you........
Bill August 08, 2012 at 09:52 PM
Ok rockfall resident, as an American you do not have "accept their ability to exist" as you put it. Heck, legally as an individual you are allowed to descriminate or be as bigoted or racist as you want, (not that I'm condoning any of the former). The restrictions are on the government, not the individual. It's not against the law, say to decide not to do business with an individual based on their race or religion, just as it is their right to let everyone know why you refused them, so that whatever group they belong to can feel free to boycott you or your business. But what the other gentleman said is true, there is an identifiable group (or subgroup if you prefer) of people who are quite willing to hang men for being homosexual, rape and kill women if the think they are lacking in fidelity, or just beat them for showing too much ankle, and worse. I do not have to recognize or respect any group that does such things. Reply
R Eleveld August 08, 2012 at 10:12 PM
Paul, If I may... I have read that the Madrassas are a hot bed of anti Western rhetoric to incite future combatants. This was reported years ago in the Wall Street Journal and may have been one of the reasons for the killing of Mr. Pearl a reporter for the WSJ. Islam at one point had spread across Northern Africa, and moved into Spain, at the same time coming across Turkey also heading towards Europe. I believe at the time The Church (RC) was going after the Knights Templar coincided with Islam retracting out of Spain. The Spanish King was not going to lock up Templars that he needed to hold back the Moors. If I may ask, do you speak Arabic or Farsi? You information sounds first hand.
R Eleveld August 08, 2012 at 10:44 PM
@Rockfall.... It seems most of the violence is reported in Europe and the US/Canada. Maybe because we have freedom of the press. I can remember the fatwah against Rushdie, that is arguably a lack of tolerance. Does this group have a similar report on the Coptics of Egypt? The women in Iran? The infidelity of woman(death) but not men that are allowed a "temporary" marriage for infidelity? The homosexuals in Libya or other Muslim countries? The Sikhs in India? The Christians and other religions in China? I am not saying that there is and/or is not persecution against other religions in other countries. Why does the report not discuss in fairness the Muslim soldier at Fort Hood killing 13? or the Muslims killing many in England or Spain over the past decade. I am not advocating violence just saying why is it not discussed in all fairness. We could spend a week doing this tit for tat. Tchjjal was just pointing out that Christians are persecuted as well. Back to the article. It was about the Sikhs and their religion that promotes peaceful co-existence, respect, and charity. Concepts we all can learn from those involved in organized religion and/or those of other belief systems, or no belief system.
Joel August 08, 2012 at 10:44 PM
Just a quick question, are you a professional blogger... You are pretty much on the forums 24/7. Just wondering.
R Eleveld August 08, 2012 at 10:52 PM
Actually no I am not a professional blogger.... You can search Maria as you can most of us real people... I find this at times to be addicting.
Mary Jo Phelps August 08, 2012 at 11:19 PM
tchjjal - As far as I know, gays are not asking for "special rights" - only equal rights.
Joel August 08, 2012 at 11:19 PM
Maria Giannuzzi No, I am wondering if Maria Giannuzzi professional blogger... She pretty much on the forums 24/7. Just wondering.
Joel August 08, 2012 at 11:37 PM
Mr. Bracer, you do live with your Mom and Dad...
Joel August 08, 2012 at 11:46 PM
Maria Giannuzzi I was asking a question that does not belong on this thread. I withdraw it. My apologies....
Dean August 09, 2012 at 12:00 AM
Bill is right, Americans do not have accept or respect what the Koran, Bible, or any other religious text has said. If it interferes with the will of the people and the Constitution of the United States, then it does not have to be given any understanding. Many cultures believe in honor killings. Americans do no have to respect that. I mean Christians do not believe in abortions and gay marriage, but that culture is not respected. Anybody from a different culture and religion that comes to America and even citizens of this country must respect that this is a country of the people and guided by the Constitution and that trumps all else.
R Eleveld August 09, 2012 at 12:21 AM
Actually you can search her on several websites. You can find the answer, if you look IN to it.
Tom August 09, 2012 at 01:44 AM
Bill while i agree with you on much, it is not legal even as an individual not to do business with someone l based on their race or religion diisability sexual preference etc. this has been law for well over 40 years and is based upon the 14th and 15th amendment under the civil rights act of 64. It clearly is not the inverse of boycotting a business.
Charles F August 09, 2012 at 04:54 AM
Dear Mr. C , the analyst in me begs to make some observations. A: Knowing or professing to know language does not actually mean one knows the situation. We know about the various self-proclaimed pundits on Fox news who claim to be experts, but their views are as narrow as any Al Qaida member. I feel that just because Joseph Walker Lindh knew English, di d not and does not make his knowledge about America accurate in the same way your possibility of knowing about Arabic, Spanish or Farsi making you knowledgeable. You have already been proven wrong on the bible issue you brought up. B: With respect to violence not being propagated from our churches. Thank God for that. This is the beauty of our Country and our Faith that we do not believe in and suggest violence. However, some people are trying to take that away from us and they are working through some of the churches through media and other means. The following is what is being said by some speakers who claim to speak on behalf of all of us: Ann Coulter: "We should invade their countries, kill their leaders and convert them to Christianity”. Baily Smith: "With all due respect to those dear people, my friend, God Almighty does not hear the prayer of a Jew." Fred Phelps: "Not only is homosexuality a sin, but anyone who supports fags is just as guilty as they are. You are both worthy of death." Gary North: "This is God's world, not Satan's. Christians are the lawful heirs, not non-Christians."
Charles F August 09, 2012 at 04:56 AM
Gary Potter: “After the Christian majority takes control, pluralism will be seen as immoral and evil and the state will not permit anybody the right to practice evil." James Kennedy: "The Christian community has a golden opportunity to train an army of dedicated teachers who can invade the public school classrooms and use them to influence the nation for Christ." Jay Grimstead: "We are to make Bible-obeying disciples of anybody that gets in our way." I can go on and on. Listen to some radio channels and some TV channels. Our churches are special but they are at risk of being hijacked by extremists. C: The violence that is being propagated by some people in parts of the Muslim Majority Countries in most places is by some within a specific group of Wahabi brand. This accounts for 5-7% of the Sunni groups. Do not believe the hate based sites numbers. Look at the Pew numbers and other legitimate studies. Their violence for the most part is focused on the people within their own faith. More Muslims worldwide are killed by these extremists than anyone else.
Charles F August 09, 2012 at 04:57 AM
It may be reasonable for you to go deeper in your “knowledge” and have independent prisms. When you wear the glasses of hate, your understanding justify more hate. Like I said before “Enough is Enough”. Please stop propagating hate and fear. Your words and call for action can be taken by some people to justify what just happened in Wisconsin. BTW, this is not a good election strategy as it harms our society. No election result is worth that. We are the best Country in the world and I want it to remain as such. May you be blessed and find enough peace and love so that fear and hate leaves your heart and mind.
Jason Vallee (Editor) August 09, 2012 at 01:35 PM
Hi Guys, Please do me a favor and try and stay on topic here or we will be forced to close this thread. Looking through the comment thread this morning, there are a lot of discussions which have nothing to do with religion, Sikhism, the Wisconsin attack or anything related to this post. Furthermore, there are other discussions which border on personal attacks. If you have any questions about what may be considered a personal attack, please read our terms and conditions. Have a good day! -Jason
Maria Giannuzzi August 09, 2012 at 01:47 PM
My comment is partially based on a fascinating non-fiction book I read fairly recently. The author travels back and forth between modern-day Egypt and India and these countries during the 11th and 12th centuries.
Maria Giannuzzi August 09, 2012 at 01:54 PM
Apology accepted. I am a professional writer and like many writers I have become a blogger as well. I also work part-time, primarily during the school year. I have been active in my community on local issues. And I have an interest in politics. I do wonder sometimes whether my efforts on these forums make the slightest difference. I certainly do not receive any tangible benefits and often am the target of some very hostile remarks. I really prefer writing for and developing my Architectural Travels blog. Architectural history is a fascinating subject and I hope to continue educating myself and communicating my knowledge to my fellow enthusiasts.
Alan Baker August 09, 2012 at 03:01 PM
Thanks Manny for the information on Sikhs, I really had no idea what sikhism was all about and it seems like a great philosophy. When I first read this article I wondered what reaction it would bring. I guess many of us could benefit from a little more spirituality and maybe less religion.
Paul Chotkowski August 09, 2012 at 06:48 PM
Mr. Eleveld, I am sorry to say that after years of intermittent study, travel, and work in the Middle East, CCASG countries, and South Asia I can not claim to speak Arabic, Farsi, Hindi or Punjabi beyond the most embarrassingly redumetaty levels. I simply have no head for languages. I am however blessed with many friends, colleagues, & first-hand in-country experiences and exposures, a reasonable library of original sources & the help of people I trust to translate. The flow of money, organization, and ideology into madrasas, mosques and disenfranchised / disenchanted Islamic communities around the world has not stopped. For example, in Nov 08 Bryan Hunt, the then Principal Officer at the US Consulate in Lahore, sent a cable to the State Department [which was disclosed by WikiLeaks # 178082] in which he stated that “financial support estimated at nearly 100 million USD annually was making its way to Deobandi and Ahl-i-Hadith [Salafis or Wahhabis] clerics in south Punjab from organisations in Saudi Arabia and the UAE ostensibly with the direct support of those governments.” More recently but before the “uprising” I spent time in Manama, Bahrain and frequented the Souq after Friday prayers at a Shi'as mosque, trust me you would have little doubt concerning the “Satans” had you been there. These are 2 of dozens of reasonably well document / personally observed data points supporting my assertions. Pretending that there is not a CLEAR and PRESENT DANGER is suicidal.
Paul Chotkowski August 09, 2012 at 06:51 PM
Mr. F, Patch is a “safe place” one can come out from one’s mother’s basement or under the bridge one calls home and use your real first and last name! Truly give it a try! It could be the first step off the dustbin of history. “What seminary did Ann Coulter attend? In which denomination was she ordained? In what ministry does she preach? Must be the church of uppity conservative white women! You appear unable / unwilling to distinguish between a person expressing an opinion and an organized religion calling for Jihad or even a fatwa. The connections between Marxists and those looking to recreate the Caliphate or those looking for the return of Muḥammad ibn al-Ḥasan al-Mahdī [the 12th Iman] are well documented. So both from a politically correct perspective and a new world order tactical perspective you put forward the view that holding homicidal muslims and their beliefs responsible for their for their savage brutality will only annoy them and may cause one to be labeled as Islamophobic, the irrational fear of being decapitated. Instead of holding Muslims responsible for their behavior, we are encouraged to treat them at worst as if they have no moral agency or at best that it is insha'Allah or maktub. If Muslims have no choice but to go on a kill spree then the only real fault lies with the people who provoked them. I have digressed too far, My deepest condolence to the families of the murdered in Wisconsin and an end to my participation in this thread.
R Eleveld August 09, 2012 at 08:00 PM
Mr. Chotkowski, I have read several accounts of militants within the Islamic community. We know of 'home grown' jihadists like the Fort Hood perpetrator, and the various bombings in Europe. This does not impugn all Muslims. Just as the killing of an abortion Dr. here in the States does not impugn all Christians. Thank you for the first hand accounts.
M Miller August 09, 2012 at 10:04 PM
Thank you Jason for your comment. I was so very impressed by this article that Manny wrote and the first 5 comments that appeared after this article. After that, the thread took a quick header. The intent of this article is not lost but its affect has been distorted by the "one upmanship" of many of these comments. This is not an article focusing on politics or religion per SE. It was written to inform the readers here about the Sikh religion in light of the horrific tragedy that occurred in Wisconsin. I worked with a Sikh gentlemen some years ago when I worked in Hartford. I recall that he was one of the kindest and most scholarly gentlemen I had ever worked with. Thank you Manny for sharing your story and I please accept the sincere gratitude behind the positive comments in this thread.
Catherine & Dennis August 11, 2012 at 03:41 AM
Thanks Manny -I too enjoyed reading your article!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »